> I just worry
> that the management pieces of it like adaptive process spawning and
> such still won't be any of their concern so we're back to having to
> find developers for it anyway.

That's a very very good point. Actually this is all about these
features. OK let's finally say that there are two main groups of
customers. Developers/admins that do projects run it on a bunch of
servers and hosting providers with server farms with lot of projects
on every server. If you need apache like pools - yes, you'll have to
find developers who want to add this - cause this is in "features"
over three years and there is nothing to say it's going to happen in
the near future. Most of developers don't need this, and we never did.
But I'd like to have production ready project with very easy
installation at least for one group of customers :) And I'd like to
have this confusing apache-like part in the conf that never worked to
be thrown away asap.

--

wbr,
fisher

can you please backport it to the individual patch for use with the
current stable version of php 5.3 please?

cause i think it will be crucial for production server to running the
stable version instead the devel or svn.

thanks in advances

On Dec 5, 7:29 am, Michael Shadle <mike...@gmail.com> wrote:
> On Fri, Dec 4, 2009 at 5:16 AM, pcdinh <pcd...@gmail.com> wrote:
> > Hi,
>
> > Antony Dovgal, one of core PHP developers has just made an
> > announcement that FPM (without PHP) has become an official PHP
> > project. Here is the full text of that announcement
>
> This was totally out of left field, I was talking to another PHP core
> dev about whether or not it should be a new SAPI or bolted on to the
> CGI/FCGI one, and then which pieces would be best (I still think the
> management daemon shouldn't be thrown under the SAPI code)
>
> No idea that Antony was working on this. It's a win though either way
> as this should help get everything up to date, the cgi_main.c version
> I believe is from 5.2.8 if that; that's probably the reason for the
> 5.3.x bugs people have been reporting.
>
> Now I have to get on top of it from this new angle and figure out what
> I can do (if anything) to keep things going now that it is looking to
> be part of PHP core... I don't want the wish list and other feature
> requests or things like that to be ignored!

2009/12/9 Jérôme Loyet <ml@fatbsd.com>:
> All I did is:
> svn checkout URL
> cd PHP_5_3_FPM
> ./builconf
> ./configure --enable-fpm
> make
> ./sapi/fpm/php-fpm -y /etc/php-fpm.conf
>
> What did you exactly do ? and what are the error messages ?

Formerly, php-fpm is a rc style script, and accepts start, stop
as its argument. Now, it's a binary file, and acts like php-cgi.
How can I stop php-fpm? Kill them? Seems not politely.
--
Ren Xiaolei

07.01.2010, в 11:54, 任晓磊 написал(а):

> Formerly, php-fpm is a rc style script, and accepts start, stop
> as its argument. Now, it's a binary file, and acts like php-cgi.
> How can I stop php-fpm? Kill them? Seems not politely.

AFAIK script is now in /ext/init.d.php-fpm, but it is not installed by
"make install".

--
Yours, Oleg Roschupkin
jjahson@gmail.com

You mean ./sapi/fpm/init.d.php-fpm file?
Yes, thank you! It IS the one I want.

2010/1/7 Oleg Roschupkin <jjahson@gmail.com>:
> 07.01.2010, в 11:54, 任晓磊 написал(а):
>
>>     Formerly, php-fpm is a rc style script, and accepts start, stop
>> as its argument. Now, it's a binary file, and acts like php-cgi.
>>     How can I stop php-fpm? Kill them? Seems not politely.
>
> AFAIK script is now in /ext/init.d.php-fpm, but it is not installed by "make
> install".
>
> --
> Yours, Oleg Roschupkin
> jjahson@gmail.com
>
>



--
Ren Xiaolei

2010/1/7 Oleg Roschupkin <jjahson@gmail.com>:
> AFAIK script is now in /ext/init.d.php-fpm, but it is not installed by "make
> install".

Does this repos still maintained? Where to report a bug?
The init.d.php-fpm file has a bug in 18th line.

--
Ren Xiaolei

That's one thing that hasn't been officially decided.

For now, I think Antony said to email him with any bugs since it's not
in php.net as a category.

Antony Dovgal <tony@daylessday.org>


On Wed, Jan 6, 2010 at 9:15 PM, 任晓磊 <julyclyde@gmail.com> wrote:
> 2010/1/7 Oleg Roschupkin <jjahson@gmail.com>:
>> AFAIK script is now in /ext/init.d.php-fpm, but it is not installed by "make
>> install".
>
> Does this repos still maintained? Where to report a bug?
> The init.d.php-fpm file has a bug in 18th line.
>
> --
> Ren Xiaolei
>

you can send bug report to tony and me.

++ Jerome

2010/1/7 Michael Shadle <mike503@gmail.com>:
> That's one thing that hasn't been officially decided.
>
> For now, I think Antony said to email him with any bugs since it's not
> in php.net as a category.
>
> Antony Dovgal <tony@daylessday.org>
>
>
> On Wed, Jan 6, 2010 at 9:15 PM, 任晓磊 <julyclyde@gmail.com> wrote:
>> 2010/1/7 Oleg Roschupkin <jjahson@gmail.com>:
>>> AFAIK script is now in /ext/init.d.php-fpm, but it is not installed by "make
>>> install".
>>
>> Does this repos still maintained? Where to report a bug?
>> The init.d.php-fpm file has a bug in 18th line.
>>
>> --
>> Ren Xiaolei
>>
>

07.01.2010, в 13:05, 任晓磊 написал(а):

> You mean ./sapi/fpm/init.d.php-fpm file?

Yes I meant exactly that one but for some mystic reason I made a big
mistake in path :)

--
Yours, Oleg Roschupkin
jjahson@gmail.com